Turbulence, Vorticity Generation and Angular Momentum Transport via the Baroclinic Instability in Protoplanetary Accretion Disk

by Hubert Klahr and Peter Bodenheimer

We present the global baroclinic instability as a
source for vigorous turbulence leading to angular momentum transport
in Keplerian accretion disks.
We show by analytical considerations and three-dimensional  radiation hydro
simulations that, in particular, protoplanetary disks have a radially
outward directed entropy gradient, which makes
them baroclinic.
Two-dimensional numerical simulations show that this baroclinic flow is
unstable and produces turbulence. These findings are
tested for numerical effects by performing barotropic
simulations which show that imposed turbulence rapidly decays.
The turbulence in baroclinic disks draws energy from the background
shear, transports angular momentum outward and creates a radially
inward bound accretion of matter, thus forming a self consistent process.
Gravitational energy is transformed into turbulent kinetic energy,
which is then dissipated, as in the classical accretion paradigm.
We measure accretion rates of $\dot M= - 10^{-9}~{\rm to~}-10^{-7}~\mbox{M}_{\sun}~
 \mbox{yr}^{-1}$
and viscosity parameters of $\alpha = 10^{-4} - 10^{-2}$, which
fit perfectly together and agree reasonably with observations.
The turbulence creates
pressure waves, Rossby waves, and vortices in the ($r-\phi$) plane of the disk.
We demonstrate in a global simulation that these vortices tend
to form out of little background noise and to
be long-lasting features, which have already been suggested to lead to
the formation of planets.

For more details have a look in Klahr and Bodenheimer ApJ submitted:
Turbulence in Accretion Disks: Vorticity Generation and Angular Momentum Transport via the Global Baroclinic Instability
See also the paper Klahr 1999, proceedings of Two Decades of Numerical Astrophysics
 TRAMP: New Insight into Thermal Convection in Protoplanetary Accretion Disks

This is a short movie on the velocity pattern in the r-phi plane of the disk. One sees the interaction of irregular waves, typical for geostrophic turbulence.

This is a MPEG1 Movie (8MB)

In order to show the growth of the instability  we created a short movie: This is the evolution of a non-axisymmetric flowpattern out of an axisymmetric one! This is a 3D radiation hydro simulation using the TRAMP code with shearing disk boundary conditions. Colours are densities, vectors are velocities in the local rotation frame. Rmin = 4.4 AU, Rmax = 5.6 AU, Height 15 degrees, azimuthal opening angel 90 degrees. This is an 17MB mpeg!
 

This is a MPEG1 Movie (17MB) about the evolution of the non-axisymmetric pattern!
 

Steady state turbulence in a 2D r-phi calculation: Density fluctuations (colors)
and Rossby waves (velocities. vectors). We remove the vertical structure and
radiation transport, but mimic the entropy gradient with a suited polytrop.

This is a MPEG1 Movie (4MB) about the evolution of the non-axisymmetric pattern!

Steady state turbulence in a 2D r-phi calculation:
Density fluctuations (colors) and Rossby waves (velocities. vectors).
But this time we model the radiation transport with a vertical
disk atmosphere model. Thus it is no artificial polytrop!
Thanks Scott!
This is a MPEG1 Movie (1.8MB) about the evolution of the non-axisymmetric pattern!
 

Our SEPLFCONSISTENT SIMULATION! This is a 3D Simulation with
radiation transport without any artificial heating. The only heat source is
the dissipation in shocks! One clearly sees the baroclinic instability form an eddy
which eventually drifts outward.

This is a MPEG1 Movie (1.2MB)
 




Hubert Klahr (klahr@ucolick.org)

last updated March 21st 2000